Skip to main content
Purchase

Homebuyer’s Appraisal Gap Guide: How to Navigate Low Appraisals & Win Your Dream Home

Published: May 30, 2024

Share
Blog Header

Homebuyer’s Appraisal Gap Guide: How to Navigate Low Appraisals & Win Your Dream Home

Finding your dream home is a process. From your initial pre-approval to the steps taken searching the housing market and submitting your offer letter, it’s not uncommon to get excited and attached to a home once you’ve had your offer accepted.

However, that excitement can quickly turn to stress if your home appraises for a price lower than your offer. Although appraisal gaps aren’t uncommon in a competitive housing market, these gaps can significantly impact your home purchase. Let's dive deeper into understanding what appraisal gaps are, their implications, and strategies to navigate them.

What is an Appraisal Gap and Why Do They Occur?

An appraisal gap occurs when a professional appraiser determines that a home's market value is lower than the price a buyer offered. This discrepancy can raise concerns for both buyers and lenders and might lead to various complications in the homebuying process.

Understanding the Home Appraisal Process

Appraisals are conducted by licensed professionals who possess extensive knowledge of the local real estate market. They meticulously analyze the property's characteristics, comparing it to similar recently sold homes in the area, known as "comps."

An appraiser considers factors like square footage, the number of bedrooms and bathrooms, the home's age and condition, any recent upgrades or renovations, and the property's location and surrounding neighborhood to land on the appraised value. By meticulously weighing these factors, appraisers arrive at a fair market value estimate for the property.

Reasons That a Home Might Appraise Lower Than Your Offer

Competitive Markets: In hot markets with low inventory and high demand, buyers often offer above the asking price to secure a home. This can lead to prices exceeding the actual market value.

Dated Comparisons: The appraiser may compare the property to those that don't accurately reflect recent market trends or the unique aspects of the home being appraised.

Seller Concessions: If a seller agrees to cover certain closing costs or make repairs, the appraiser might lower the value to offset these concessions.

How an Appraisal Gap Can Impact Your Offer

Appraisal gaps have far-reaching implications for buyers. Mortgage lenders rely heavily on appraisals to ensure they're not lending more money than a home is worth. If a gap exists, the lender won't loan you the full amount needed to cover your offer and can force you to make up the difference in cash.

This unexpected financial burden can be a major obstacle for many buyers, especially those looking to buy their first home or those without substantial cash savings to cover the difference.

A low appraisal can be used as leverage to renegotiate the price with the seller. However, this isn't always successful, especially in competitive markets where sellers may have other offers. Additionally, renegotiations can delay the closing process and create tension between parties.

What to Do If Your Home Appraises Lower Than Your Offer

Facing an appraisal gap can be daunting, but it's not the end of the road. These strategies can help you overcome this hurdle and potentially get your homebuying journey back on track:

Cover the Gap with Cash: The most straightforward solution is to pay the difference between the appraised value and your offer price in cash. However, this is only feasible for buyers with ample savings.

Renegotiate the Price: If the seller is motivated, you can try to negotiate a lower price based on the appraisal. This requires strong negotiation skills and a willingness to compromise.

Challenge the Appraisal: If you believe the appraisal is inaccurate, you can dispute it by providing additional evidence of the property's value, such as recent comparable sales data or information about renovations or upgrades the appraiser might have overlooked.

Order a Second Appraisal: Sometimes, getting a second opinion from a different appraiser can reveal a different valuation. However, this comes at an additional cost and may not always yield the desired results.

Exercise Your Appraisal Contingency: Many real estate contracts include appraisal contingencies and clauses that allow buyers to back out of the deal if the appraisal falls short of the offer price. These contingencies often come with deadlines, so it's important to act fast if you wish to exercise them.

Appraisal gaps are a common but often stressful aspect of the homebuying process. By understanding what they are, their impact, and the available strategies for addressing them, you can confidently navigate this obstacle and make informed decisions to secure your dream home without compromising your financial well-being.

If you experience an appraisal gap or have any concerns about a potential appraisal gap before submitting your offer, feel free to reach out to your UMortgage Loan Originator for expert financial guidance.

Related Posts

MortgageJune 17, 2025
What Are Seller Concessions? A Simple Guide for Homebuyers and Sellers
What Are Seller Concessions? A Simple Guide for Homebuyers and Sellers Buying a home comes with a lot of upfront costs. Between the down payment, closing costs, prepaid taxes, and insurance, the amount you owe at closing can add up fast. That’s where seller concessions can come in. Whether you're a homebuyer looking for a little financial relief or a seller trying to attract more offers, this guide will walk you through what seller concessions are, how they work, and how they benefit both sides of the transaction. What Are Seller Concessions? Seller concessions are when the home seller agrees to pay certain costs on behalf of the buyer as part of the purchase agreement. Seller concessions most often cover things like title fees, taxes, insurance, and other expenses that come due at closing. Instead of reducing the sale price of the home, a seller might agree to pay some of the buyer’s costs to help make the purchase more affordable. It’s a way to get creative with negotiations, especially in a market where buyers may be struggling with high interest rates or limited cash. How Do Seller Concessions Work? Here’s an example: Let’s say you're buying a $300,000 home and ask the seller to contribute 3% of the purchase price ($9,000) toward your closing costs. If the seller agrees, that $9,000 can go toward things like your appraisal fee, loan origination fee, or even buying down your interest rate. The key thing to remember is that seller concessions must be negotiated upfront and written into the purchase contract. Your mortgage also needs to allow them, and each loan type sets limits on how much a seller can contribute. We’ll touch on that shortly. What Can Seller Concessions Cover? Seller concessions can be used to cover many of the upfront costs involved in purchasing a home, including appraisal fees, title insurance, loan origination fees, property taxes, and homeowners’ insurance. Seller concessions cannot be used for your down payment or to help a borrower qualify for the loan; they’re only allowed to cover closing costs and prepaid expenses. Seller Concession Limits by Loan Type Each loan program has its own rules about how much a seller can contribute. Here's a quick breakdown: Conventional Loans: Less than 10% down: The seller can contribute up to 3% of the home’s price. 10% to 25% down: Up to 6% in concessions allowed. More than 25% down: Up to 9% in concessions. Investment properties: Only 2% allowed, regardless of down payment. FHA Loans: Flat 6% seller concession limit regardless of the down payment amount. VA Loans: The seller can contribute up to 4% in concessions, in addition to paying for standard closing costs as permitted by the VA. This 4% can be used to pay off a buyer’s debt, cover prepaid expenses, or even fund a temporary buydown. USDA Loans The seller can contribute up to 6% of the home’s purchase price toward the buyer’s closing costs and prepaid expenses. Why You Should Negotiate Seller Concessions as a Homebuyer or Seller Seller concessions have plenty of benefits for both homebuyers and sellers. Here’s why you should consider them depending on your side of the transaction. How Seller Concessions Benefit Homebuyers Lower Out-of-Pocket Costs: Concessions reduce the cash you need to bring to the table at closing. Easier Loan Approval: By lowering your upfront costs, you may have more flexibility in choosing your loan program or interest rate. Buydown Opportunities: You can use concessions to buy down your interest rate, which can lower your monthly payment for the life of the loan. How Seller Concessions Benefit Sellers Attract More Buyers: In a market with less demand, offering concessions can help your home stand out and attract more buyers. Faster Closings: Buyers who receive concessions may be more motivated and financially ready to close on time. Higher Sale Price: In some cases, sellers can offer concessions instead of reducing the list price. Seller concessions are a powerful tool that can make homeownership more accessible for buyers and help sellers move their homes more quickly. Whether you're buying or selling, working with a local mortgage expert can help you understand exactly how seller concessions fit into your overall game plan. Ready to talk through your options? Follow this link to get connected with a UMortgage Loan Originator near you.
READ MORE
Market UpdateMay 30, 2025
How the Federal Reserve Impacts Mortgage Rates (And How It Doesn't)
If you’ve been watching the news lately, you’ve probably seen a lot of headlines about the Federal Reserve and interest rates. And if you're a homebuyer or a real estate agent working with buyers, you might wonder: Does the Federal Reserve control mortgage rates? It’s a great question. And the short answer is: Not necessarily. The longer answer is a bit more nuanced because while the Fed does play an important role in the economy, it doesn't directly control mortgage rates. What Is the Federal Reserve and the Federal Funds Rate? The Federal Reserve—often referred to simply as the Fed—is the central bank of the United States. Its primary job is to keep the economy healthy by keeping inflation in check, supporting the labor economy, and promoting stable & sustainable economic growth. One of the main tools the Fed uses to manage the economy is the Federal Funds Rate. This is the interest rate banks charge one another for overnight loans. While consumers don’t pay this rate directly, it has a ripple effect across the economy, influencing rates on credit cards, auto loans, and savings accounts. How the Federal Funds Rate Influences the Economy When the Fed raises the Federal Funds Rate, it becomes more expensive for banks to borrow money. That tends to result in higher borrowing costs for consumers and businesses in an attempt to slow down inflation and prevent the economy from overheating. When the Fed lowers the rate, borrowing becomes cheaper. This encourages more spending and investment, often a strategy used during economic slowdowns or recessions. Important distinction: The Federal Funds Rate influences the economy, but it does not directly control mortgage rates. Why Mortgage Rates Don’t Always Follow the Fed Here’s where a lot of confusion begins. Many people assume that when the Fed raises interest rates, mortgage rates automatically rise too. But that’s not how it works. Mortgage rates are driven by a different set of economic factors, mainly the bond market. Specifically, rates are closely tied to the 10-year Treasury yield and the performance of mortgage-backed securities (MBS). Investors who buy these securities care most about the labor market, inflation, the long-term economic outlook, and market stability/instability If inflation is rising or expected to rise, mortgage rates tend to increase. If economic conditions appear weak or uncertain, rates can fall, even if the Fed is raising the Federal Funds Rate. In fact, mortgage rates often move in anticipation of what the Fed might do, not just in response to what it has done. The markets are always looking ahead. What Really Drives Mortgage Rates? Here’s a quick snapshot of the major factors that impact mortgage rates: Inflation: Higher inflation usually = higher mortgage rates. Economic Growth: A strong economy can lead to higher rates. Global Events: Uncertainty (like geopolitical conflict or pandemics) can drive rates lower. Bond Market Demand: More demand for mortgage bonds often = lower mortgage rates. In other words, mortgage rates are influenced by a wide range of factors and are always forward-looking. Want more in-depth analysis of the housing market? Check out our weekly Housing Market Update blog. How Homebuyers and Real Estate Can Navigate the Market For homebuyers and the real estate agents supporting them, the key takeaway is this: Don’t assume that a Fed rate cut means mortgage rates are going down. In some cases, mortgage rates don’t move much on the day that the Fed cuts rates. Most of the time, they will drop in the lead-up to a Fed Meeting if a rate cut is expected. Other times, they might drop after a Fed announcement, depending on how markets interpret the economic outlook. If you’re considering buying a home or are an agent for a hesitant buyer, here’s how you should navigate periods of market instability: Focus on personal goals and timing, rather than trying to time the market. Work with a knowledgeable mortgage professional who can explain how market shifts impact your unique situation. Make informed decisions based on the bigger picture, not just headlines. Whether you're buying, selling, or considering a refinance, UMortgage Loan Originators are here to help you navigate the market with confidence and leverage homeownership to build wealth. If you’re curious about your homebuying or refinance options and want expert guidance, fill out this form to get connected with a UMortgage Loan Originator in your area!
READ MORE
PurchaseApril 8, 2025
How to Seamlessly Sell Your Current Home and Buy Your Next One
As a homeowner, you've already taken one of the biggest and smartest steps toward building long-term wealth. But what happens when your current home no longer fits your needs? It’s more common than you’d think. In 2024, 76% of homebuyers were already homeowners. When you’ve put together the savings for a down payment and built equity by paying your mortgage every month, buying your next home becomes a lot easier. But even for experienced homeowners, the process of selling and buying at the same time can feel overwhelming. Whether you're upsizing, downsizing, or relocating, this guide will walk you through what actually happens when you sell your home to buy another one—plus the financing solutions that can help you use your existing equity without creating extra financial stress. What Happens to Your Current Mortgage When You Sell Your Home? If your mortgage is paid off by the time you list your home, you get to pocket the profit from the sale after closing costs, repairs, and any buyer contingencies are accounted for. If you still owe a balance on your mortgage, the proceeds from the sale will first go toward paying off your remaining loan. This happens during the closing process, and any remaining profit—also known as your equity—comes back to you. For example, if your home sells for $400,000 and your remaining mortgage balance is $250,000, you’ll walk away with the difference (minus closing costs and agent commissions). That’s nearly $150,000 in potential funds to use toward your next home purchase. If your home sells for less than what you owe (rare in today’s equity-rich market), you may need to bring money to the closing table or work with your lender on a solution. Your UMortgage Loan Originator can walk you through all scenarios so you’re never caught off guard. How to Use Your Current Equity to Move Up into Your Next Home Equity is your secret weapon when it comes to moving into your next home. It's why repeat buyers in 2024 put down a median of 23%—the highest in over two decades. When it’s time to make your next move, the equity in your current home can be used to: Make a down payment on your new home Cover closing costs (on both transactions) Reduce the size of your new mortgage This is especially helpful if you’re moving into a more expensive home. When you have access to funds upfront, you can avoid mortgage insurance, reduce your monthly payments, and potentially secure better loan terms. The key is timing. To unlock your equity, you usually need to sell your current home first or explore financing options that allow you to tap into that equity before the sale closes, which we'll cover next. Programs That Help Existing Homeowners Buy Their Next Home Selling and buying at the same time can feel like a juggling act. Luckily, UMortgage offers several solutions that can make it easier—especially if you want to buy before you sell. HELOC (Home Equity Line of Credit) A HELOC lets you borrow against your home’s equity while you still own it. Think of it like a credit card with a revolving line of credit. You can use the funds as a down payment on your new home, and then pay off the HELOC once your current home sells. This is a great option for homeowners with significant equity who plan to sell shortly after purchasing their new home. Bridge Loan A bridge loan is a short-term loan that “bridges” the gap between buying your new home and selling your current one. It typically uses your existing home as collateral and comes with terms between 6 months and 3 years. Bridge loans are typically used in one of two ways: To make a down payment on your new home: Great if you can’t afford two mortgages at once. To pay off your current mortgage and cover your next down payment: Best for homeowners with a relatively low mortgage balance. Because they come with higher interest rates than traditional mortgages, bridge loans work best for buyers with strong credit and a solid plan to sell quickly. If your home takes longer to sell than expected, you could end up managing two (or more) monthly payments. Home Sale Contingency A home sale contingency allows you to make an offer on a new home that’s dependent on your current home selling first. It protects you financially in case your existing home doesn’t sell in time. Just keep in mind that in a competitive market, sellers may favor buyers without contingencies. Your UMortgage Loan Originator can help you weigh the pros and cons. What to Consider Before You Sell Selling your home to buy a new one is one of the greatest wealth-building benefits of homeownership. But with so many moving parts, it’s important to plan ahead. Here’s where to start: Evaluate Your Equity & Finances Start by estimating how much equity you’ve built. Subtract your remaining mortgage balance from your home’s current value. Not sure what your home is worth today? Your UMortgage Loan Originator can provide a free home value assessment. Next, look at your full financial picture. Review your income, debts, and monthly expenses to determine what kind of mortgage you’ll qualify for on your next home. A mortgage pre-approval can give you clarity and a competitive edge. Set Your Timeline Try to align your sale and purchase timelines to minimize the gap between closings. This helps you avoid the hassle of temporary housing or paying two mortgages at once. A coordinated closing—where you sell and buy on the same day—is possible with the right planning and support team. Prep Your Home for Sale Making your home market-ready is one of the best ways to boost your sale price. Small upgrades like fresh paint, curb appeal improvements, and professional staging can make a big difference. Consider a pre-listing inspection to catch any potential deal-breaking issues early. While it might add to your upfront costs, it can save you time and stress once offers start rolling in. Moving Up Requires the Right Team Moving from one home to another is a big life event—but it’s also a major financial opportunity. The equity you’ve built can be a powerful stepping stone toward your next goal, whether it’s a bigger space, a better location, or a smarter investment. The key is having a plan and the right people in your corner. If you're ready to explore your options and discover what will help you maximize the wealth-building benefits of homeownership, get in touch with your UMortgage Loan Originator. They'll help you run the numbers, set a timeline, and create a plan that fits your needs so you can move up with confidence.
READ MORE

Get approved in just minutes!

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Review our complete Privacy Policy here.